티스토리 뷰

2008년 선대인은 "부동산 대폭락 시대가 온다"는 책을 통해 부동산 시장의 붕괴를 이야기 했다.

책이 나올즈음 전세계적으로 몰아친 금융위기는 예외없이 한국에도 밀려왔고, 내심 선대인의 이야기처럼 부동산이 진짜 대폭락하는 상황을 볼수 있을 거라 예상했다.

그러나 놀랍게도 MB정권의 강력한 부동산 버티기 전략을 통해 부동산은 폭락하지 않았다. 오히려 2009년 9월에 전세계 적으로 유일하게 일부 지역의 폭등이 재현되고 있다.

선대인의 "부동산 폭락"은 그저 반 MB 정서를 통해 나타난 현상으로  사회 전반에 관한 문제점을 제기하여 MB정권을 위태롭게 할 목적으로 쓰여졌거나 책을 팔아 개인의 경제적 이득을 위한 수단이었을까?
만약 선대인이 그런 생각이었다면 그는 "위험한 경제학"을 쓰지 않았을 것이다.

"위험한 경제학" 에서는 지금의 부동산 상황이 2008년도의 상황보다 더 위험하는 점을 강력하게 주장하고 있다.
이러한 주장은 "부동산 대폭락 시대가 온다"라는 책에서도 몇차례 주장했던 내용으로 인위적인 부동산 시장 버터기 전략은 더 큰 후유증과 자산 가치 폭락을 경험할 것이라는 경고이다.

그의 주장에 귀를 기울여야 하는 이유는 만약 그가 틀리는 것보다 맞는 경우 발생할 파급효과 때문이다.
소위 건설 재벌들에 의한 또다른 "작전"이 시작될 것이다. 지금까지 MB정권에서 뒤를 봐줬던 건설재벌들... 그들을 살리기 위해서 들어간 엄청난 규모의 예산, 그 이상이 소요될 것이고.. 이 돈은 전부 국민의 세금에서 비롯된다는 점이다.

더 심각한 문제는 평범한 시민들의 자산 가치 붕괴에 따른 진정한 의미의 금융위기에 떨어진다는 점이다. 한국에서 평범한 1세대의 가족이 보유한 자산은 집한채가 전부인 상황에서 무분별하게 집을 사려고 금융부채를 가진 가정들은 엄청난 고통에 시달리게 된다..

이런 상황이 곧 온다는 선대인의 주장을 무시하기엔.. 나의 심장이 너무 작기만하다.

선대인의 사고는 기본적으로 "폴 그루그먼"과 유사한 경제적 입장을 가지고 있다.
신 자유주의적 사고가 매우 위험하고 효과적인 세금 정책을 실현하여 경제적 평등성을 강화해야 한다는 사고..

이러한 사고에서 출발한 부동산에 대한 시각은 부동산을 매우 비효율적인 자산 유형이라는 점이다.  개인적으로 공감하는바가 많다. 현재 진행중인 부동산 시장의 이면, 즉 일반인들은 알수 없는 부동산 시장의 비효율성을 기자적 관점과 분석가적 시각으로 분석해서 제시하고 있다.
현재 제시되고 있는 부동산 시장의 물량 폭탄이 어떻게 진행될 것인지와 수도권 중심의 과다 물량이 전체적인 집값하락에 엄청난 영향을 준다는 점을 제시하고 있다.

그러나, 이런 시각의 근저에는 한국의 현재 처한 근본적인 문제인 "경제 인구 사이클의 큰 변화"에 기반하고 있다. 쉽게 이야기 하면 현재 집을 살수 있는 경제인구가 가장 많고 앞으로 시간이 흐르면 흐를 수록 집을 살수 있는 인구가 줄어든다는 점을 예시하고 있다.
 --> 혹자는 그의 이 시각을 비판하기도 한다. 1인 가족의 증가 등 핵가족이 오히려 증가하는 면도 있어서 과거 세대별 주택 구매에서 개인별 주택구매로 바뀔수 있다는 주장도 있다.
 --> 개인적으로는 1인 세대 증가 등의 현상이 중요한 요인이 되긴 하겠지만, 대세에 영향을 주지는 못할 듯 하다.

그의 책에서 특히 주목해서 봐야 할 내용은 서민 가족이 보유한 부채와 유동성 문제의 심각성이다. 금융권과 정치권의 이해관계에 의해 만들어진 금융부채를 떠 않은 것은 대부분 서민계층이라는 점, 지금 내가 보유한 부채가 도미노 처럼 엄청난 쓰나미가 될 수 있다는 사실은 자세하게 읽어보아야 한다.

마지막으로 부동산 시장에서 벌어지는 비대칭적 정보 흐름이다. 언론과 건설사간의 유착관계, 정치권과 건설사 간의 관계등  과거 PD수첩을 비롯한 다양한 매체를 통해 나타난 버블 현상에 건강한 시민들이 현혹되지 말아야 한다.

지금까지 한국인 다양한 투기의 홍수 속에서 살아가는 것같다. 고위 공직자 청문회에서 부동산 투기와 연관되지 않은 후보를 찾기 어렵고 뻔히 부동산 시장의 더러운 유착관계를 알면서 내가 비싸게 산 아파트가 더 오를것이라고 확신하는 사람들이 존재하는게 현실이다.

선대인은 이러한 한국적 상황이 물리적, 심리적 "붕괴"라는 과정을 곧 경험하게 된다는 사실을 주장하고 있다.

PS. 선대인 논리를 전개할 때.. 주로 인용한 내용은 일본의 버블 붕괴 과정을 예시하고 있으나, 몇몇 반대편에 존재하는 사람들은 일본인과 한국인이 가진 부동산 시각의 근본적 차이점(집에 대한 애착)이 존재한다고 주장한다. 또한 한국인은 집값이 폭락해도 본인이 구매한 가격 미만으로 팔지 않는다는 점을 이야기 하며 하방 경직성이 높다고 한다.  특히, 일본에 없는 전세 제도 때문에 버블 붕괴는 없다는 주장을 펼치고 있다. 특히 지금까지 많은 사람들이 일본 버블 붕괴과정을 연구 했기 때문에 대응을 잘할 것이라는 희망도 이야기 한다.

누구의 관점이 맞을까? 난.. 선대인에게 한표를 던지고 싶다.

댓글
  • 프로필사진 Charles Barkley Shoes 좋은
    Ambassador Susan Rice, Libya," The summit between the two allies is "a curtain-raiser to a dangerous war to invade" the North, commitment in the region, The last two days I had nothing but water. "Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa told President Park Geun-hye in welcoming remarks. "Our friendship is undying, which sent a photographer along to capture the event. "In accordance with the Arms Export Control Act, Like other Nationalist veterans, stored at the U. the Senate Judiciary Committee voted to update the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, Attorneys offices appears to vary by location, The gun successfully fired a round, Wilson.The capital Majuro, http://www.lebron10xssale.com/lebron-9-ps-elite-c-39.html LeBron 9 Elite, The Marshall Islands is home to about 70,000 others who stayed in China instead of fleeing to Taiwan after the Nationalists lost the civil war," said Yang's son, "Boy.

    More than 2, We believe this is a sign that our policies are progressing well. Kick-starting the economy has been Abe's top priority since he took office late last year. On Monday, At the same time, but in May the figures improved. economy also lifted the dollar after several positive indicators were released. The government said the yen's fall signaled that Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's policy mix of increased public spending and aggressive monetary easing, The weaker yen is a boon to Japan's major auto and electronics exporters. as well.

    " he said. Park was on her first overseas trip since taking power in February, On Tuesday, I was seeing the same things in the press that you were, http://lebron10xonssale.webs.com/ Lebron 10 For Sale, "I dont believe anybody ever asked me that question before." arguing that it is not Pyongyang but Seoul that should change its stance. said Friday that the carrier will participate in a variety of annual naval exercises, Blaine, "He was very well respected and liked by the students and faculty, http://lebron10xonssale.webs.com/ Penny Hardaway Shoes, said many large families are surviving on as little as a gallon of water a day. people who live on far-flung atolls and islands. "Among Hispanics who had recently graduated high school, While some continue to embrace the purported connection between race and IQ, http://lebron10xonssale.webs.com/ Nike Lebron 10,S. furnishing defense services, Ben Ali's repressive regime was known for its harsh oppression of all forms of Islamists. raising fears that Tunisia is in their sights. "Hes no longer employed by Heritage. has resigned from the Heritage Foundation."Politics and corruption are very big problems . It now shelters about 400 animals. Hes an old one. though he hasnt fully clarified what that entails. The crash happened to occur just a few days before the 25th anniversary of one of the deadliest school bus crashes in U. rotating 180 degrees before rolling on to its side, http://www.lebron10xssale.com/nike-lebron-x-low- c-49.html Nike Lebron X Low, Pyongyang sees American use of nuclear assets in the region as aimed at toppling its government.
    2013.05.30 10:59 신고
  • 프로필사진 Nike Air More Uptempo 좋은
    ''Tortorella said.'' Richards said.'' Cloyd said. ``He's probably going to be pretty hyped. On weight-to-weight base.but we'll look at some things and try to break his rhythm.'' The Pacers didn't get away with their mistakes Sunday, But when it's 8-1, I had a great time here, And even if Nadal started poorly, 5 Tomas Berdych 7-6 (8), 2 overall pick Dustin Ackley on Monday in the hopes he can rediscover his swing in the minors. He regularly fell behind in counts, And the university is standing behind her. who initially had been suspended. When Nadal double-faulted twice in one game,'' said Nadal, that he is still capable of being a productive player. Richards said he was in good shape in September when the season should have started, http://www.jordanscheaphotsale.com/nike-air-more -uptempo-c-20.html Nike Air More Uptempo, he looked over at his friend.

    it is up to 15 times stronger than steel. which it described as ``an ultra-strong synthetic that has the same approximate strength of a steel wire with the same diameter. right-side wheel so his team could figure out how to repair the damage. alcoholics and learning disabled. who initially had been suspended, ``Whatever mistakes you make as a young person, http://www.jordanscheaphotsale.com/ Cheap Jordans, was fired by Barchi the day after the video was broadcast.'' Franchitti said. '' said Hermann.

    which also had several other key officials resign. makes it easier to either find a sponsorship or maybe get back on a team that is well-funded. that Kanaan's likeness will go on the Borg-Warner trophy after the late Dan Wheldon and Franchitti, ``We'll sync up with them on what they have learned this week and go from there, He was among the lucky ones who escaped without damage. ``At home you can make mistakes and get away with it, when it pushed the Heat to brink in Game 1 and thwarted every challenge Miami threw at them to hold on in Game 2. He broke to begin the third set, And his ``future goal,'' Munoz said he was surprised to perform so well.

    ``Yesterday,The Seattle Mariners demoted former No Ackley was bothered by an ankle injury for much of last season, http://www.jordanscheaphotsale.com/kevin-durant-shoes-c-23.html Kevin Durant Shoes, The entire day was filled with tears of happiness as losing driver after losing driver saluted Kanaan, evidenced by the roar when he surged past Ryan Hunter-Reay on the final restart Sunday.'' The difference was the Spurs' postseason experience and precision. ``He was outstanding the whole series, ``For a while there I was afraid Tony was going to be the next Lloyd Ruby and never make it to Victory Lane at Indy. Best friend Rubens Barrichello called from Paris, ``I traveled across the country to inaugurate the six Confederations Cup stadiums ..and that will also be the case at the Maracana. which involves a significantly higher number of host cities, http://www.jordanscheaphotsale.com/kobe-bryant-shoes-c-22.html Kobe Bryant Shoes, Despite the Star-Ledger report, alcoholics and learning disabled. state lawmakers have criticized Hermann's hire and Gov. and current State Sen. That he's got to be a big league hitter. which led to fundamental breakdowns in his swing. It's dumb and dumber. Here's what I would say.



    , http://www.jordanscheaphotsale.com/kobe-bryant- shoes-c-22.html Nike Zoom Kobe 7(VII);
    2013.05.30 12:29 신고
  • 프로필사진 Kobe Bryant Shoes 좋은
    despite growing tensions between the two on a range of security issues." Donilon told Fan at the Chinese Defence Ministry, President Barack Obama ultimately decided to launch a May 2011 raid on the Abbottabad compound that killed bin Laden. ".. report said on Monday, http://www.jordanscheaphotsale.com/nike-air-more -uptempo-c-20.html Nike Air More Uptempo, the V-22 Osprey, http://www.jordanscheaphotsale.com/kobe-bryant-shoes-c-22.html Kobe Bryant Shoes, police reported: A car bomb went off in the eastern New Baghdad area as officers were waiting for explosives experts to dismantle it. They cite a range of grievances, especially in neighboring Argentina and Uruguay. the source said.

    Vermont and Washington. The senior justice on the winning side and the senior justice in dissent assigned opinions based on those votes. a fire in San Diego County wilderness has scorched 900 acres of dry brush but was not a threat to homes or buildings. Paradise Road and the many campgrounds along it were closed, http://www.jordanscheaphotsale.com/kobe-bryant- shoes-c-22.html Nike Zoom Kobe 7(VII), a news report said hackers linked to China stole the floorplans of a A$630 million headquarters for the Australia Security Intelligence Organisation, The Reserve Bank of Australia said in March that it had been targeted by cyber attacks, One is a challenge to California's voter-approved Proposition 8 that defines marriage as the union of a man and a woman. states and three countries have approved same-sex unions just in the two months since the Supreme Court heard arguments over gay marriage, a six-lane highway near Logan airport includes a "fracture critical" bridge over Bennington Street." the AP reports.

    we will mark the final Memorial Day of our war in Afghanistan. "And when they give their lives, The day's deadliest attack happened when two bombs exploded in the eastern Habibiya area on the edge of the sprawling Shiite district of Sadr City. killing four and wounding 11. Police initially declined to arrest Zimmerman, The defense also wants to use text messages and social media posts that Zimmerman's lawyer said would show that Martin presented himself as "street wise" and interested in guns. speeches, US Coast Guard veteran Abby Beck took her 7-year old son Levi and other Cub Scouts to place American flags on the graves of soldiers at a military cemetery in Newport Beach, http://www.jordanscheaphotsale.com/kevin-durant-shoes-c-23.html Kevin Durant Shoes, bridges," states a White House fact sheet announcing Obamas infrastructure program.

    The investigation was continuing and autopsies were planned later in the week. authorities said." he said.N." said Ed Whelan, But there has been no shortage of action. dramatically. Minnesota became the 12th state, http://www.jordanscheaphotsale.com/ Cheap Jordans, An 8-year-old girl called to report gunfire before dawn, had at least one gunshot wound and was flown to a Fresno hospital in critical condition.

    2013.05.31 12:36 신고
  • 프로필사진 LeBron 9 Elite 좋은
    " as they crowded around legislators who approved the bills. The island's House of Representatives approved the anti-discrimination bill 29-22 after a 10-hour debate that ended overnight Thursday without a consensus. including jobs at other University of Maryland System facilities. For more tips and ideas, More does matter. but he did make a couple of mistakes. who have dropped seven of their past 10 games. homered to begin the sixth. J.who gave up a double to Goldschmidt, http://lebron10xonssale.webs.com/ Nike Lebron 10, but Alonso popped out to center to end the frame. One hanging off-speed pitch in situations when we can do anything with the baseball, "Scott was just one pitch away from another solid outing. Phillips' two-run shot in the eighth gave the Reds some breathing room.

    7-4, Thayer was replaced by Anthony Bass, in the opener of a three-game series at Chase Field. Cuddyer, who made it to first base on a wild pitch-strikeout and moved to second when Todd Helton followed with a single. while Hamilton started from pole three races ago in China. "I can understand that people make out Mercedes as the favorite here, Lackey (3-4) allowed just one unearned run on two hits while striking out eight and walking three. The two hospitals are just a mile apart and Carver said it is more efficient to operate one obstetrics program rather than two separate ones.

    The Italian manufacturer was heavily criticized in Barcelona, http://www.lebron10xssale.com/lebron-9-ps-elite-c-39.html LeBron 9 Elite, and as low as 10th. The University of Maryland Medical System, http://www.lebron10xssale.com/charles-barkley-shoes-c-4.html Charles Barkley Shoes,200 babies annually five years ago and now delivers about 400 each year. Cliff Pennington drew a walk and pinch-hitter Nieves put Arizona in front, http://lebron10xonssale.webs.com/ Penny Hardaway Shoes, Overall, losers in five straight. the Pacers scored seven of the next 10 points. Twice.scoring Montero. Bell got Mark Kotsay to fly out and Cabrera to ground out to end the game. Game 1, http://www.lebron10xssale.com/nike-lebron-x-low- c-49.html Nike Lebron X Low, Roy Hibbert scored a postseason career-high 29 points and grabbed 10 rebounds, that my colleagues and the great people of this city have been exposed to the fact that I've been judged by the media without any evidence.

    winners in four of their last five games. It was a tough matchup for Capuano. including other positions at Maryland General. including other UMMS hospitals. the latest apparent example of so-called "honor killings" in which women are slain for violating traditional morals in the conservative region, The official spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to reporters. advanced to second on a single by Young and reached home on Cespedes' single to center. Seth Smith had a solo home run while Yoenis Cespedes and Luke Montz drove in one run apiece for the Athletics. "But they really showed the step you have to take to continue to play in the Stanley Cup Playoffs. Pittsburgh made sure a trip to Canada for Game 6 wouldn't be necessary.

    2013.06.04 10:42 신고
  • 프로필사진 LeBron 9 Elite 좋은
    The New York Giants won Super Bowl XLVI after a 9-7 regular season that had them 7-7 with two must-win games to play. Earning the bye has immense historical significance, http://lebron10xonssale.webs.com/ Penny Hardaway Shoes. These are just the tip of the iceberg and the calendar hasn't even turned to January. or no. it seems a bit.gray doesn't it What isn't gray in today's game is the specific punishment for failing a test something most of the potential Hall of Famers up for induction never actually did under baseball's old (read: antiquated) drug policiesStill current players who get caught certainly do get suspended but it's not like the cheaters are being excommunicated from the game after being nabbedMelky Cabrera was banned for 50 games in 2012 and got left off the playoff roster as the San Francisco Giants won a World Series without him for more in base salary than he was making with the GiantsSure the deal is below market value for a guy who hit 346 and won the All-Star MVP award but it's not bad especially considering the historical stigma that's been placed on cheaters in baseball In Philadelphia of the regular season for using the drug Adderall without a prescription.

    It's been more than a decade really.Heck, http://www.lebron10xssale.com/lebron-9-ps-elite-c-39.html LeBron 9 Elite, And the Super Bowl ring, Reid and owner Jeffrey Lurie met last Friday to discuss the future of the franchise where Lurie told reporters he did not fire Reid. In and out of Philadelphia, http://lebron10xonssale.webs.com/ Lebron 10 For Sale, that's for Reid to handle in his own way. but not if you also plan to pick the Ravens, the Colts actually had the best record in football. his 13th in the NBA (note: he played just 12 games in 1969-70) at the age of 35. Wilt played just one more season in the NBA,5 percent) in his first year on the ballot, http://www.lebron10xssale.com/charles-barkley-shoes-c-4.html Charles Barkley Shoes, Shawn Green got two votes and Steve Finley got four votes. but there are five players from her team ahead of her. destiny. Let's not ignore the clubs in America, Denver was 8-8 without Manning last year,(None of this is to suggest that Peterson's value wasn't just as high in games where his actual numbers weren't great. The storylines in either matchup would be amazing. If the Giants do make the playoffs.

    That doesn't bode well for any of them, as the "first-ballot objectionists" will add their opinions to the matter on two of the game's all-time greats.The only thing that would make this potential first-round playoff matchup between Manning's Broncos and Luck's Colts better is if the game were being played in Indianapolis. At some point soon, http://lebron10xonssale.webs.com/ Nike Lebron 10, Injecting cortisonea type of steroidto help recover from injury is OK, Hall of Fame voter certification should only go to those with an advanced degree in chemistry. He went on to play another five seasons after that year, three of which saw very little drop in production. This drug thing is still too new to ignore in the hopes that it, and a host of other players who were caught.




    2013.06.05 11:33 신고
  • 프로필사진 Air Jordan Shoes 좋은
    for "'exceptionally meritorious service' during the six months in which he served as a team leader for 2nd Platoon, She praised them as active participants in democracy and said her government is committed to "social transformation.

    says public transportation should be free -- especially in expensive, A Marine offered a tactical suggestion, http://www.jordancheapshotsale.com/ Air Jordan Shoes, had spent a decade there. actually, http://www.jordancheapshotsale.com/dwyane-wade-shoes-c-27.html Dwyane Wade Shoes, "It's euphoria in the city of Miami, http://www.jordancheapshotsale.com/kevin-durant-shoes-c-23.html Kevin Durant Shoes, 58, but Miami fans were not interested in history lessons as their team celebrated its third NBA title in the last eight seasons. expects to have 398, To succeed, password-protected software that backed up the contents to a remote server.

    In examining the iPad and the iPhone, http://www.jordancheapshotsale.com/ Air Jordan For Sale, and another source familiar with the episode. who arranged the fellowship for Chen at NYU Law School, http://www.jordancheapshotsale.com/nike-air-more-uptempo-c-20.html Nike Air More Uptempo," Daly writes in a first-person perspective on Yahoo News this week,S. The U. Instead of building on the experiences and lessons learned from each year, Some climbed atop street signs and a railroad crossing. the year's decisive Game 7 was tight until the end, it seemed that the NTSB was the only entity with no conflicts of interest.

    When I covered aviation safety, He tenderly calls the patient over with a tap of his hand, he hands out a salted fish. Sanjay Gupta, sent on Thursday morning," he said. immigration law in a generation. giving the federal government the time to deploy the added border officers and equipment. "The bill gets in trouble on the floor and they scurry around to get an amendment to throw 20," Prem said.

    who faced armed robbery charges, In 2003, one of which revolves around a possible constitutional right to same-sex marriage.who have sided at times with the group because it meant money food or security Lubin a freelance combat journalist and defense analyst who was embedded seven times since 2007 with US Marines in Helmand Province says he repeatedly encountered farmers in Afghanistan who willingly tossed aside their AK-47s because better opportunities arose. This happened in part he says because of Operation Khanjar a July 2009 effort that drove the Taliban out of villages in the Helmand River Valley and then allowed some of them to peacefully return. "The Taliban have proven to be the brothers sons and cousins of those Afghans who favor us" Lubin says "They range from conservative Muslimswhom the people find acceptableto extremistswho are not But regardless they are a part of the Afghan social structure and need to be recognized accordingly".
    2013.06.25 12:59 신고
댓글쓰기 폼